The Lobster Rolls On

September 2, 2016

From starring on Showtime’s hit drama “The Affair” to creating a gluten-free menu, Andrea Anthony’s beloved Montauk restaurant continues to surprise—even after 50 years.

Andrea Anthony had plans to become a psychologist. That all changed one morning in 1977, when the manager of her then-husband’s restaurant quit, and she stepped in to run the business. In the nearly 40 years since, Anthony has come to understand one of the universe’s most indelible truths: that trying to plan for life is about as foolproof as running a restaurant in Montauk.

In the New York summer haven often referred to as “The End of